Thinking Wars America:
5. Every Child Gets Ahead

Posted by Bob on October 11th, 2007

“No Child Left Behind” is legislation that leaves every child behind. It simply does not prepare the 21st century learners for the world they must address. This is a world that requires Generative Thinking Skills. This is legislation that delivers only conditional responding skills.

Generative Thinking Architecture

The mission of Generative Thinking is to create responses where there were none. Indeed, the precise definition of Generative Thinking is as follows:

To create responses that the stimuli were not intended to elicit.

In other words, thinking generates new and more productive responses to the continuously-changing stimulus conditions of our time.

There are three sets of processing systems involved in Generative Thinking:

  • Relating to elicit images;
  • Representing to develop new images;
  • Reasoning to generate or create the most productive images.

These processing systems are transformed into thinking skills in systematic training programs.

Relating Skills

The first set of processing skills emphasizes “Relating to Elicit Images.” This means that we employ our “Information Communication Skills” to obtain images of any phenomena or circumstances (See Figure 4):

  • Responding accurately to get others’ images;
  • Initiating operationally to give our images;
  • Negotiating merged images of phenomena.

Relating is the essential beginning phase in Generative Thinking because it yields images of conceptual information with which to reason.

thinking_wars_f04.gif

Figure 4. Relating to Elicit Images

Representing Skills

The second set of processing skills emphasizes “Representing to Develop New Images.” This means that we employ our “Information Representing Skills” to develop new images of any phenomena or circumstances (See Figure 5):

  • Sentences or conceptual levels of information;
  • Systems or operational levels of information;
  • Schematics or dimensional levels of information.

Relating is the necessary transitional phase in processing because it yields us images of operational information with which to reason.

thinking_wars_f05.gif

Figure 5. Representing to Develop New Images

Reasoning Skills

The third and culminating set of processing skills emphasize “Reasoning to Generate the Most Productive Images.” This means that we employ “Information Reasoning Skills” to generate newer and more productive images of any phenomena or circumstance (See Figure 6):

  • Exploring by expanding images of information;
  • Understanding by narrowing images of information;
  • Acting by defining information objectives.

Reasoning is the culminating phase in Generative Thinking because it yields us new and more productive information objectives for acting.

thinking_wars_f06.gif

Figure 6. Reasoning to Generate More Productive Images

To sum, the three phases of Generative Thinking are “nested” or “housed” in generative thinking:

thinking_wars_f07.gif

Figure 7. The Phases of Generative Thinking

Relating elicits the images that Representing develops and Reasoning processes generatively. Systematically trained and implemented, Generative Thinking creates totally new images of information with which we can create our own changeable destinies.

In summary, perhaps the most grievous harm of “No Child Left Behind” is this: because we actually “swallowed the bait—hook, line and sinker,” we got “stuck” with the “switch, hook line and stinker”—the empty promises that we made and “kept” to our children.

We placed the students in “double jeopardy.” Those who were initially “held back” by adults, were now systematically “held back” by their teachers, all in the name of “leaving no child behind.”

In transition, the best thing that can be said about “No Child Left Behind” is that children are learning the wrong things. The worst thing that could be said is that they are getting “dumber” as they achieve higher standards.

Our conclusion may be best represented by the question asked by the “Prime Mover” of this legislation:

“Is the children learning?”

Comments

  1. Rick Bellingham Says:

    Dear Bob,

    What you’ve presented here is the case for the new 3Rs of education. We need to teach our children to relate by creating new responses to changing conditions and by elevating images in collaboration with others. We need to teach our children to represent the information with which they are continually bombarded through multi-dimensional schematics. And we need to teach our children to reason with their newly represented information and to act after they have processed, not before. What the No Child Left Behind promulgators did was to simplify before processing because they were afraid of the complexities given their incompetence and resisted the complexities given their lack of curiosity. We can only simply after we have worked our way through the complexity. And our solutions will only be as good as our processing capabilities and our willingness to explore multiple sources and understand all the variables. You have generated a system that will help us create sustainable solutions.

  2. George C. Banks Says:

    Dear Bob,

    I think this was a very well articulated analysis of some of the issues facing our educational system. I think one of the main themes that I’ve drawn out of this is not only is No Child Left Behind failing to teach our children knowledge, it’s failing to teach our children how to think. Children are not given a framework for understanding their forced memorization, nor are they learning to identify critical components of materials in order to ask questions and apply what they’ve learned.
    As you said they are not learning to generative thinking. In today’s world with so much change what knowledge you possess is not nearly as important as having the ability to think critically. Because the “most important knowledge” of the time is changing so quickly it’s more important to know how to learn and to think. Your 3Rs model is an answer to this challenge.

  3. Sue Mackler Says:

    Dear Bob,

    As you and Rick and George have stated, the new 3Rs will help children meet their thinking requirements. The 3Rs will help children interact with their world and in their world with all the promises that freedom and thinking provide.
    But how will children learn these 3 Rs from a world where maturity of modeling and teaching are often missing? How will children know what relating, representing, and reasoning are when their teachers, their parents, their leaders are too busy, too afraid, too distracted? Will the children get ahead of the so called adults. Perhaps if we are lucky, the children will create an answer we are no longer offering as a choice.
    So, the bumper sticker phrase is not a prescription for the children as it has been operationalized but perhaps a representation of a concept to wake up the sleeping adults in the world before the children are left to find their own way. There is no child who should be left behind or left as an orphan if mature adults were relating, representing, reasoning with each other and for each other and for others.

    I think one of the first steps in helping to insure that no child is left behind is that all adults must be awakened to thinking about freedom. Your freedomblog is a great first place for informing this thinking. Thanks for doing your part by establishing a freedomblog, defining the ingredients and models for thinking, continuing to lead the building of reason and perspective, and for acting with full intention. Thank you for your continued commitment to challenging our thinking.

  4. Sue Says:

    Dear Bob,

    I dream of freedom, of peace, of kindness, of relationships, of ideas, of humanity, of …………..

    As a teacher, a woman, a mother, a daughter, these are thoughts that have never lost their meaning in my mind, my body, my words, and hopefully my actions. However, after reading your freedomblog.com postings, it is very clear that these are not words alone. Each of these concepts rests on some basic assumptions – embedded principles:

    • Freedom requires responsibility, action, and thinking
    • Peace is a decision to relate and to act with full reasoning
    • Relationships require listening, understanding, action, and feedback
    • Ideas are the source of growth and possibilities
    • Full humanity requires learning

    But you have also shown how these words are not only concepts and principles. There are additional standards and skills that can be learned and modeled.
    • To live free and to help others live free requires skills, systems, and models. To live free requires a commitment to others.
    • To create peace requires the skills for relating to others, to the world and the skills for generating of new forms of wealth: information, human, financial.
    • To relate to others and to the world requires listening and helping skills
    • To reason is to know how to understand the current conditions and to be willing and able to generate goals and systems to move forward. To reason is to be willing to act.
    • To create ideas requires the skills to see and hear the needs and requirements of today as the base for creating and representing new ideas.
    • To enjoy humanity requires the power and the skills to fall in love with a new idea, a new person: to have skills to learn from the world.

    And so, the ability to relate, to represent, to reason are skills (the necessary conditions) that will help the children of the world take a step to being free and to enjoying the benefits of kindness, of peace, of a full humanity (the new standards). The new 3Rs will help ideas such as freedom and peace be possible. The new 3Rs will help operationally insure that we meet changing standards. The new 3Rs will help generate the highest common denominator for the next moment. Without the tools to relate, to represent, and to reason, the beauty of abstract thoughts such as freedom is lost in a dream. These are the skills that can help fulfill the promises inherent in such words as freedom, peace, and ideas.

    Perhaps it is time to want freedom, peace, kindness, relationships enough to pay the price to learn how to relate fully, respond accurately, and reason to create new initiatives that make words such as these live for all the children. Perhaps we can create an educational model that helps children and the world build dreams such as these. There is little doubt that if we really want these dreams to come true, we must pay the price to learn the skills that make the standards of freedom, of peace, of ideas possible.

    And so, can we ask the American people to vote for freedom, for peace, for creation of ideas for all children? Is there a Presidential team that understands that these abstract concepts are all possible if we make a commitment to building skills in relating, representing, and reasoning for freedom, for peace, for dreaming, and for growth? Is there a moment in this very complex world where dreams can become more than dreams?

We welcome your comments below:

Comments will be moderated.

     
     
    Brought to you by Carkhuff Thinking Systems, Inc.

    Contact Us
    triamcinolone ointment tube sizes cyklokapron oral uses baclofen pill id clindamycin hcl tablets how long will i have to take finasteride baclofen rsd imuran fluid retention tretinoin soap reviews does finasteride cause frequent urination can u take zantac while nursing lamictal zoloft klonopin is there a generic prometrium which is better differin or retin a butalbital and topamax who makes isotretinoin xeloda method of action nystatin triamcinolone neomycin taking aspirin and metoprolol aldara efficacy genital warts trileptal generic vs name brand does finasteride promote hair growth cutting imdur use of naltrexone for alcohol abuse renagel sut side effects of imdur tablets azulfidine allergy does procardia cause hair loss thorndale avenue artane warfarin vs aspirin atrial fibrillation new perspectives dulcolax chills beli tretinoin neurontin morphine side effects zantac for babies renova avage and differin dramamine for 3 year old bus from city centre to artane dutasteride 12 months prescription drug asacol isotretinoin website metformin help with hair loss dilantin signs and symptoms diamox and weight loss differin lotion reviews tegretol success stories active ingredient in topamax diltiazem sinus congestion can you take benadryl and nasonex order xalatan online can carafate cause hair loss does zantac heal esophagus how to take metoprolol succ er neurontin dosing esrd clindamycin cause tiredness lamictal paxil interaction tretinoin topical patient information meclizine bioavailability topamax gi upset formula to correct dilantin level for albumin harga glucovance 500 imuran and weight gain clomiphene citrate hair loss how soon can u get pregnant after depo provera asacol dailymed metoprolol positive inotropic topamax for thyroid is it safe to take zantac while breastfeeding do you need a special license to prescribe naltrexone differin no effect aricept max dosage depo provera lump at injection site imuran msds topamax weight loss dosage pain meds without aspirin or tylenol active ingredient in anacin and bufferin retinol or renova provera urination taking lamictal and zoloft depakote er weight loss what is dramamine 2 dilantin and thc clindamycin uti dogs how long does tretinoin cream take to work on acne scars diltiazem package insert hospira desloratadine hair loss arcoxia 90 mg does zolpidem cause hair loss dramamine make you sleep low dose naltrexone and oxycodone diltiazem and loss of appetite clindamycin lotion for face dog hair loss after prednisone lamictal for rapid cycling bipolar dilantin cyclosporine isotretinoin health risks diltiazem ace inhibitor highest mg of neurontin clindamycin phosphate gel usp reviews buy provigil online in u.s clindamycin phosphate topical solution and birth control how much weight loss on metformin lioresal syrup norvasc calcium supplement interaction metoprolol side effects itching does propecia or rogaine work clindamycin phosphate directions does rogaine contain propecia lamictal hair loss supplements wellbutrin weight loss drug aricept from canada what is triamcinolone acetonide ointment used for cpt depo provera injection mestinon and drinking alcohol therapeutic use of dilantin clindamycin okay while breastfeeding how does dilantin affect the liver prometrium inserts side effects aygestin coupons arava hair loss hair loss on lamictal lamictal rash armpits is dramamine safe for 2 year olds differin gel avis prometrium soy allergy depo provera first injection triamcinolone injection scalp synthroid high calcium levels tretinoin cream and psoriasis coumadin aspirin stroke drug interaction with dilantin drug bank of rosuvastatin calcium carafate after meals zantac and h pylori stool test anacin formulation finasteride hair loss mechanism crixivan indinavir sulfate imuran platelets tretinoin cream 0.1 directions use finasteride 3 times a week neurontin and weakness avodart hair loss cure finasteride mechanism of action ppt does relafen get you high lamictal risks does neurontin cause seizures lamictal makes you happy which is better for fever ibuprofen or aspirin lamictal as a treatment for depression meclizine ear congestion can clindamycin help a sinus infection metoprolol tartrate molecular structure cytoxan and taxotere long term side effects can you buy infant zantac over the counter what topamax dosage causes weight loss baclofen and valium suppository sinemet and drinking alcohol cluster headaches and topamax methocarbamol with aleve lamictal keeps me awake low dose naltrexone hypothyroidism isotretinoin gel for rosacea prozac and tegretol for bipolar depo provera shot when is it effective vyvanse topamax desloratadine clarinex reviews viagra and baby aspirin nuvigil versus provigil side effects lamictal pregnancy side effects can depo provera cause digestive problems levitra erectile dysfunction does lamictal make you shake what dosage of topamax for migraines metoprolol itchy skin does finasteride work yahoo clindamycin price walmart topamax vs depakote for seizures apa hydroquinone tretinoin triax pharmaceuticals tretinoin cream depo provera and weight gain loss diltiazem coated beads brand name metoprolol for headaches clindamycin wound infection dose is zantac an anticholinergic does provera help with heavy bleeding retin-a tretinoin cream 05 topamax to stop drinking alcohol trileptal manufacturer novartis mestinon overdose symptoms metoprolol succinate what is it for can ativan be used as a sleep aid differin en antibiotica generic topamax for seizures neurontin after stroke xeloda alopecia is aldara safe to use during pregnancy clindamycin phosphate lotion vs gel clindamycin achillessehne metformin 2000 mg and weight loss is topamax an opioid finasteride works for hair loss sotalol or metoprolol can topamax cause low white blood cell count differin moisturizer after dramamine after gastric bypass can you use aricept and exelon together phentermine hoodia buy neurontin and dramamine anti nausea medication dramamine naltrexone addictive trileptal gabapentin interaction clindamycin dosage in cats diltiazem and antibiotics wellbutrin vs adderall for weight loss tretinoin vs differin sucralfate carafate side effects does lamictal help with bipolar depression avodart formulation nystatin and triamcinolone acetonide seborrheic dermatitis xeloda leg swelling lamictal and lithium for depression how to take oral clindamycin for acne diltiazem dosing atrial fibrillation metoprolol cause rectal bleeding meclizine and promethazine accutane skin hyperpigmentation back acne differin spironolactone helps weight loss clindamycin for dogs ear infection how does provera induce period drinking on clindamycin hcl 300 mg can i take clindamycin for a uti clindamycin dosage staph infection provigil paypal siberian ginseng and thyroxine can you take meclizine and ativan together what is the side effects of tegretol how effective is meclizine for vertigo sotalol and metoprolol in combination cytoxan iv push xanax with metoprolol clindamycin for group b strep zantac 300 mg bid dilantin level after loading dose renagel drug action piroxicam for pain relief provera 10 mg dose parkinson's disease sinemet aspirin interaction with simvastatin benzac crema brufoli combination warfarin and aspirin depo provera tired how long does it take for triamcinolone to work skin peeling from differin can a dog take benadryl and aspirin propecia vs rogaine reviews how often check dilantin levels olanzapine dosage information diamox wyeth dramamine for ear ringing topamax ophthalmic side effects can clindamycin cause night sweats triax tretinoin cream does amoxicillin affect the yasmin pill eating after taking xeloda finasteride and androgel triamcinolone cream vs ointment stievamycin tretinoin erythromycin clindamycin phosphate not working isotretinoin 20 mg forum zantac and baking soda starter pack of lamictal meclizine hcl bonine act now program actonel does metoprolol interact with grapefruit differin paula choice tretinoin 0.1 percent risedronate actonel side effects can aldara cure hpv manfaat obat actonel isotretinoin crohn's disease prescription zantac 150 asacol 400 mg benzac acne aid toner bha differin toprol drug classification dramamine how much to get high when would you hold metoprolol can keflex cause erectile dysfunction prednisone interaction with aspirin naltrexone impurities intrathecal baclofen pump failure why aspirin and plavix topamax and cymbalta dilantin overdose ppt cytoxan fda approval date isotretinoin review uk free actonel metoprolol tartrate in chf topical isotretinoin acne mircette vs ortho cyclen olanzapine fainting how long on fosamax does clindamycin have ceclor imitrex on drug screen doxycycline hyclate and keppra tegretol uses anxiety xeloda no insurance clarinex coupons 2012 cost for prometrium tramadol 50 mg aspirin clindamycin safe dosage prometrium help acne foods to avoid when taking sinemet topamax erectile dysfunction neurontin bg back pain relief motrin imitrex false positive drug screen fosamax 5 mg tablet provigil neck pain neurontin dailymed can trazodone cause hair loss oxytrol discount coupon meclizine hydrochloride drowsiness zoloft weight loss side effects can you sleep on provigil dramamine weight dosage effectiveness of casodex aldara for hair loss muscle pain caused by lamictal adverse effects atrovent topamax with neurontin is tretinoin good for under eye circles will zantac harm my unborn baby therapeutic levels of prograf clindamycin and differin regimen l-tryptophan effexor metoprolol tartrate dosage range triamcinolone acetonide ointment india does finasteride make hair fall out accutane joint pain relief tretinoin cream 0.025 makeupalley lamictal side effect hair loss pms-olanzapine odt bus from artane to dublin airport triamcinolone acetonide ointment uses high levels of dilantin effects sinemet cost clindamycin bei phlegmone metoprolol winianu carbamazepine calcium interaction arcoxia tablets what are they used for rogaine and propecia together prometrium drug interactions provera shed uterine lining metoprolol-actavis succ 95 finasteride sigma how to treat acne caused by depo-provera does famvir cause hair loss benadryl and aspirin overdose clindamycin azithromycin allergy baclofen dosage amounts what is olanzapine used for yahoo neurontin and appetite lamictal drug class is clindamycin similar to erythromycin use of neurontin in dogs lamictal side effects coordination avodart savings coupon compare topamax and lamictal does zantac help seasonal allergies lamictal and eye problems elocon 0.1 liuos iholle finasteride online australia metoprolol cardiac output does clindamycin treat tooth infections how much is provera 10mg in mercury drug dulcolax suppository usage arava tablete forum tretinoin cream wash face side effects of metoprolol forum is olanzapine a stimulant best way to take neurontin how does neurontin work for pain diltiazem side effects bleeding arcoxia filmdragerad tablett cytoxan adriamycin taxol can zantac be given im arava and alcohol consumption how much asacol can you take average dosage of provigil metoprolol succinate and headaches metoprolol and lexapro interactions permanent tsb artane branch lamictal vs valproate does saw palmetto work as well as propecia clindamycin mip 300 alkohol does zocor cause erectile dysfunction does baclofen cause drowsiness how to use tretinoin cream correctly isotretinoin suppliers differin gel gut information on drug neurontin generic name for zantac 150 erectile dysfunction anxiety viagra does synthroid have calcium maximum dose of xeloda bone density loss with depo provera trileptal weed what is the generic for relafen lamictal driving how to take trileptal what do neurontin look like topamax running triamcinolone acetonide suspension toxicity to corneal endothelial cells metoprolol succinate iupac name skin rashes from lamictal can take vicodin aleve revia drug test mixing topamax and weed lamictal and decongestants difference between avodart and proscar price of naltrexone clindamycin hcl and benadryl dilantin used for anxiety hair loss and neurontin zantac dosage for 20 pound baby can depo provera cause shortness of breath xeloda and elevated bilirubin why does topamax make me tired aricept moa lamictal annos iv loading dose of dilantin olanzapine and ovulation diltiazem blood pressure medication does tretinoin cream 05 work weight loss phentermine and topamax rifampicin and clindamycin therapy what type of drug is depo-provera clindamycin is bactericidal fincar wiki provigil medication and weight loss why no alcohol with zantac a1 chipper artane menu isotretinoin literature tretinoin used for wrinkles isotretinoin china copegus roche lorazepam side effects weight loss arava chemotherapy drug synthesis of dilantin from benzaldehyde carafate contents zantac after eating is triamcinolone acetonide cream good for ringworm taking provera and still bleeding taking aspirin with propranolol can taking prometrium help you get pregnant minoxidil accutane hair loss weight gain when stopping topamax stopping avodart cold turkey imodium ad and zantac high avodart vs finasteride hair loss dramamine with prozac parlodel dosage forms pain relief for plavix users aricept side effects anorexia rogaine propecia combination results dramamine life like weeds can lamictal 100 mg get you high prometrium 100mg cost clindamycin phosphate ampoule does asacol expire triamcinolone acetonide open wound topiramate 25 mg for weight loss o2 artane castle phone number what is the difference between colace and dulcolax can i take codeine with aleve doxycycline hyclate cause hair loss can you get pregnant while on depo provera shot mixing imitrex and fioricet can you take zantac for gastritis what does asacol contain drug interactions with sinemet is tramadol effective pain relief where to buy nimotop goodrx tretinoin coupon tacrolimus and diltiazem atrovent nasal solution isotretinoin and long qt elocon for itching baclofen pump stroke spasticity weight gain with provera phenytoin to keppra conversion topamax 25 mg street value neurontin sleep aid plavix vs aspirin side effects using tretinoin for wrinkles alendronate calcium absorption aldara cream watson wikipedia aldara cream can you take tums with zantac 150 carpet express artane opening hours